From Study XVII, Exhibit 19

No House Democrat has scored right of a Republican since 2003

Source. Voteview, share of Democrats right of most liberal Republican

Method and data

Method. Democrats with a nominate_dim1 score above the lowest Republican score in the same chamber and Congress, divided by Democrats scored. One member at the edge sets the threshold; the pairwise share in the text uses every member. House counts include Delegates and the Resident Commissioner, and the tested removals of those rows and of members with 13 or fewer votes leave every tested count unchanged. Senate Democrats are party code 100 only; counting independents as Democrats raises the Senate count by one in the 92nd through 97th Congresses and leaves the zeros since 2005 unchanged.

CongressFirst yearHouse Democrats right of most liberal RepublicanHouse Democrats scoredHouse Democrats right of most liberal Republican (%)Senate Democrats right of most liberal RepublicanSenate Democrats scoredSenate Democrats right of most liberal Republican (%)
8019477219437.11234748.94
8119497226726.97236137.7
8219516224025.83225143.14
8319536021827.5285315.09
8419553223513.62145127.45
8519573324013.75165330.19
8619594828616.78156722.39
8719615027318.32146521.54
8819634626217.56136918.84
8919654630115.28147020
9019675625022.4116417.19
9119695025020115818.97
9219715325920.46105617.86
9319734124616.6765710.53
9419754729415.995618.2
9519774929416.6776510.77
961979262819.254596.78
971981242479.720460
981983222728.090460
9919851825770470
1001987162626.110550
1011989152655.660560
1021991132704.810580
103199362622.290570
104199552082.40480
105199732121.420450
106199932131.411462.17
107200122140.931502
1082003020801482.08
1092005020300450
1102007024300500
1112009026500660
1122011020000530
1132013020400570
1142015019000440
1152017020000480
1162019024000460
1172021023200490
1182023022100520
1192025022200450

Download the-narrow-middle-03-overlap.csv

Download SVG · CSV. Data and chart licensed CC BY 4.0.